It really was excellent, and IMO it's the first "comic book movie" that transcends the genre to become a real film. Everyone here should go see it! Great acting, directing, action, and story-telling! Christian Bale and Michael Caine are great together, and Liam Neeson was in top form. And Gary Oldman and Morgan Freeman were great too and both instantly likeable. But my favorite character was Dr. Crane/The Scarecrow played by Cillian Murphy (28 Days Later). What a knock-out actor! He was so fantastic I couldn't believe it! I wanted to see more of Scarecrow, his screen time was way too limited.
My main gripes: extremely tight editing (the movie felt crammed). And the fact it ended.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bb195/bb1951c9cacc3d766f9b0ea663b81dc9221184fa" alt="Razz :P"
And the musical score by James Newton-Howard and Hans Zimmer was just emotional stuff, I loved it. Some people might prefer Elfman's score but I prefer the Newton-Howard/Zimmer one, there's so much depth to it. An Oscar-worthy score for sure!